Overview of my Journey with Multimodal Learning and Assessment
For the past two years, I have been researching and studying multimodal learning, multimodal literacy, and multimodal assessments. The state of Georgia and the DeKalb County School District's emphasis on standardized and local multiple-choice tests and essays to determine student mastery of the state standards sparked my interest in these topics. Regardless of the school or county I taught in, students in general-level classes consistently struggled on these assessments. The issue of these students underachieving and consistently not meeting the proficient threshold has not sparked any major changes or suggestions on how to help these students improve or be able to display their learning. As a result, I decided to conduct a study where students would take the county-provided unit 1 assessment and then complete a multimodal summative project of my creation. My hope was the study would be the first in a continuing effort to affect change in my individual teaching context.
why is multimodal learning so important?
Transcript: Multimodal learning and its effect on student literacy is something I have been exploring, through research. Throughout the majority of my tenure as a high school English teacher, traditional means of teaching and assessing student learning have been emphasized as being the best means of determining if students are meeting our state standards. As each year passed and technology became increasingly ingrained in our lives, students became less and less responsive to the traditional means of teaching and learning. I began using movie clips, educational videos, and images more frequently to assist students with connecting to the literature. I also began to offer them options to use their multimodal skills when being assessed.
After reviewing my students’ multimodal projects, I always felt as though I could see the skills they learned throughout the unit, and their ability to analyze the text we read. For me, this is much more valuable than the results I would have received from a test, or even a traditional essay. The results from this kind of study would be beneficial to me and other teachers who are interested in shifting to multimodal learning in their classrooms. It would also allow me to provide relevant research when having discussions about this with my administration.
What is multimodal Learning?
Transcript: Hello. I wanted to kind of delve deeper into why multimodal learning has become so popular over the past ten years, why it is valid and important, and why multimodal learning should be incorporated into the 21st-century high school literature classroom on a regular basis.
The first thing that I wanted to focus on was what multimodal learning is in general. And essentially, multimodal learning is a way of teaching and learning that incorporates various modes such as pictures, illustrations, audio, speech, writing, imprint, music, movement, gestures, and facial expressions to make meaning. These modes can be used individually or in conjunction with one another. So the main thing with multimodal learning, in general, is it is not meant to erase writing and print. It's not meant to erase the importance of writing and print. However, it definitely is something that can supplement the teaching of reading and writing in a traditional fashion. One thing that I mentioned in my paper and was just something that I've noticed as well is that technology has become or technology is rapidly changing in our current society and it's become a very important part of our current society, social media as well. As a result, this current generation of students that are high school aged, so from 14 to 18, essentially their whole lives revolve around the use of technology, social media, consuming images, consuming video, and reading text a lot less than what maybe previous generations have. As a result, what is happening in the classrooms has to change or adjust as well. But a lot of school districts have been slow to make these required changes and multimodal learning is a part of that.
Another thing to think about with multimodal learning, and I'm going to go ahead and shift here, is that also includes the idea of multimodal literacy. So multimodal learning and multimodal literacy go hand in hand and you can't really have one without the other. So our traditional idea of literacy is the skills associated with reading and writing. So a student's ability to read and a student's ability to write and the skills that we teach have always been directly connected to reading and writing and a student's ability to do so. But now that times are changing, we have to also consider students out of school literacies, which is another. A phrase that you see in a lot of the research associated with multimodal literacy and multimodal learning and out-of-school literacies are basically those skills that students may have that are things they may be engaging in, those modes that they may be engaging in outside of school that are not normally or atypically taught or addressed at school. So, their ability to find a video and create meaning with it, find images and create meaning with it, what they're doing on social media, then blogging and what that means. So, there are a lot of things that students are doing outside of school that could be beneficial in an academic setting, but it's not being used in that fashion, so teachers aren't really addressing that.
Another thing I want to talk about with multimodal literacy is the idea that it's not just solely on what they can do with the modes, how they manipulate modes to make meaning, but also the perspective. Students are approaching these texts from multimodal text and regular text. What underlying context is associated with that multimodal text? What underlying context is associated with the student themselves? So, what perspective are they approaching the text with? Because a lot of the research I read also points out that no student approaches a piece of literature or a multimodal text from the same perspective. So, that also has to be considered when a student is being taught and you're bringing in these multimodal assignments into the classroom.
The next thing I wanted to bring up was the idea of multimodal text and what that is, because teachers sometimes will be told about multimodality, you should be more multimodal, have your students use multimodal skills. But teachers are not being shown how to do it and how that looks. So I did want to incorporate that as well. With the multimodal text, I do mention that that includes graphic novels, comics, websites and blogs, and that these are all supplemental options to assist students in increasing their engagement and their performance. Because many students are not as engaged when it's the rote reading and writing approach, and they do disconnect, they don't perform as well. B ut, if you can bring in these graphic novels specifically, and use them as a supplemental tool not to replace but to supplement that, they can be very effective in re-engaging those students who have checked out and aren't as interested specifically when you're reading a more difficult classical text. For example, with Macbeth, I'm a firm believer in supplementing with the graphic novel, whether that be having the student read the original version first in its entirety, and then circle back and read the graphic novel version, whether that be using excerpts from the graphic novel only of the more important scenes in the play to help students get an even further or deeper understanding and also to be able to visualize because this is how students are learning out and it's their natural way of learning and what they're doing outside of school. So bringing some of that into the classroom I think is very helpful.
I also talk about multimodal assignments. Specifically, I focused on remix journaling and multimodal projects mostly because those are the two things that I think are simple and easy to incorporate into a classroom for a teacher, specifically a literature teacher. So, remix journaling, essentially it's taking the idea of journaling that many high school literature teachers are already doing and adding that multimodal component. So having students journal, so use text, but also bringing in images, bringing in video clips, and maybe even music to supplement the meaning that they're making from the reading. So being able to make meaning not just with their words, but with those other modes as well, is very important. And I think it's great with the remix journaling because it does help to increase the critical analysis skills once again, their engagement, and then their overall performance as well because they are interacting with that text on a deeper level than they would have if they had just simply done written, handwritten, or typed journaling without all the additional components. And the multimodal projects would take that even a step further by having a student use an extended period of time to create or work on a project that does have a multitude of multimodal components. And once again, it's that higher level thinking, higher up on Bloom's taxonomy, but at the same time including those multimodal components.
And then finally, I wanted to display what teachers can do to bring in their multimodal skills. Because if you're constantly as a teacher asking students to be multimodal, use their multimodal skills, and incorporate that into their learning, but you're not showing them how to do it and you're not doing it, then you may have less buy-in and less success with the strategy. So, I wanted to just show a couple of strategies teachers could use. So I focused on multimodal scaffolding and anchoring. So, multimodal scaffolding is basically the same thing as regular scaffolding, which is something that many teachers are taught to do. But you're adding multimodal components, so you're adding those images, you're bringing in paintings in, having students maybe look at that before they read a certain text and interpret. You're bringing in clips, you're bringing in songs and lyrics, maybe other videos to help with that scaffolding process as you build up to a particular skill or to a particular reading and anchoring kind of piggybacks on that, except it's solely based on clips. And it's really encouraging teachers to use video clips daily, or as much as they can, so that students are seeing that multimodality in the classroom on a regular basis. And finally, these are my sources. These are all the sources that I consulted and read.
About Me
I am Janee Blake and this is my 14th year as a high school literature teacher. I have taught reading, gifted students, accelerated students, general level students, as well as students designated as Special Education. I have taught 9th grade literature, 10th Grade Literature, World Literature, and British Literature. I have always looked for ways to enhance my students' level of interest in my classroom and their ability to express what they have learned.
This interest led me to the world of multimodal learning and how multimodal assessments can benefit students. This website is dedicated to my exploration of using multimodal projects as assessments versus assessing using essays or tests.